Two tarballs of my little puzzle program, same commit. Different SHA-256. Unpack them and every single regular file compares equal. I got so fed up with checking differences that I changed the welcome message in one copy just to watch the comparison fail for a good honest reason.
Back on the untouched originals: same file order in the listings, same owners, same modes. These are plain tar files. What bit of the biscuit am I not weighing?