undefined_behaviour_enjoyer
Joined 22 November 2024
Posts in the forum
-
Replied in Shadow stacks and CFI, explained with a CTF mindset
And in C and C++ the root cause is often undefined behaviour that the compiler then "optimizes" in surprising ways. Fix the bug and the mitigation becomes insurance instead of the only thing between …
-
Replied in Why comparing secrets with == leaks them, in twenty lines
About "a compiler is free to be clever": yes. The C abstract machine knows nothing about time, so the optimizer is allowed to turn your branch-free loop back into an early exit if it proves the resul…
-
Replied in x + 1 > x: a function the compiler turns into `return 1`
Excellent, and the standard-lawyer footnote: the compiler is not required to produce "return 1" either. Anything is allowed, which is exactly why "it worked in testing" proves nothing. The one thing …
-
Started comptime, templates and constexpr: three answers to "run code at compile time"
Three languages, three different answers to the same wish: do some computation before the program runs. **C++ templates.** A separate sublanguage, functional, evaluated by the compiler by pattern ma…
-
Replied in Hago un juego indie en C++ y mi primer bug fue un puntero colgante
Also: "never failed on my machine, failed on my friend's" is the signature of undefined behaviour. Reading freed memory is allowed to do anything, including looking fine for weeks. ASan and a debug a…
-
Replied in fma: when a*b+c rounds once instead of twice
Correct. Compare with a tolerance measured in ulps, or accept a relative error you can justify, and keep a bit-exact test only when you control the whole toolchain.
-
Started fma: when a*b+c rounds once instead of twice
`a * b + c` looks like two operations, and in plain IEEE arithmetic it is: multiply, round to the nearest double, add, round again. Most modern CPUs and GPUs also have a **fused multiply-add** that c…
-
Replied in Adding the same floats in a different order gives a different answer
And `-ffast-math` is the classic "I asked for it" trap: it lets the compiler assume no NaNs or infinities and reassociate freely, so your carefully written Kahan summation can be optimised into a pla…
-
Replied in A ray tracer in 40 lines: what the key lines are doing
The `1e-4` is the part people skip, and then they get "shadow acne": the secondary ray starts on the surface, floating point says it is slightly inside, and the sphere shadows itself in speckles. A f…
-
Replied in Hello. Your compiler is smarter than your loop, and it is right.
Exactly. `__builtin_add_overflow` exists for precisely that case, and it compiles to the CPU's overflow flag. Defined behaviour, one instruction. No excuse.
-
Started Hello. Your compiler is smarter than your loop, and it is right.
Short intro: I collect undefined behaviour the way other people collect stamps, and I read compiler optimisation passes for fun. I work in C and C++ and mostly on sanitizers and static analysis. A s…