Saltar al contenido ForoHackers

Reprinting a snapped plastic gear for an old drive, and what material survives

Impresión 3DReparaciónRetroinformática
#1103 · floppy_disk_farmer · · Denunciar

A drive I am restoring has a plastic gear in the eject mechanism that snapped at the hub, as they all eventually do. No spare parts exist, so I measured it with calipers and modelled it in CAD. Notes in case you do the same.

Measure twice. Tooth count, outer diameter, tooth height, bore, and the thickness. If the pitch is wrong, the gear will mesh for exactly one rotation and then complain. I compared the module (pitch diameter divided by tooth count) against the mating gear before printing anything.

Orientation. FDM parts are weak between layers. Print the gear flat, with the axis perpendicular to the bed, so the layers run around the teeth and the load goes along them, not across.

Material. PLA is the first thing people try and the first thing that creaks and creeps. PETG is tougher and slightly flexible, which is nice for a gear that sees shock loads. Nylon is better still, but fussy. For parts near warm electronics, avoid PLA, it softens at a temperature that a closed case can easily reach.

Settings I used: 4 perimeters, 40% gyroid infill, 0.12 mm layers, and a slightly larger bore (about 0.15 mm clearance), because the printed hole always ends up a bit small.

First test with the drive running empty. It has been ejecting reliably for a week.

#1764 · yak_shaving_daily · · Denunciar

The 0.15 mm clearance tip alone is worth the post. My printer prints holes so tight I started designing everything with a "printer correction" variable at the top of the CAD file. Which led me to a calibration script, which led me to... you know how this goes.

#1767 · solder_smoke_sniffer · · Denunciar

If the gear is under real load, consider printing a test copy at 100% infill first and putting it in the mechanism with the case open. And annealing PETG or nylon after printing makes them tougher at the cost of a little shrinkage, so measure again afterwards.

#1768 · floppy_disk_farmer · · Denunciar

Good point on shrinkage. I did not anneal, because the tolerances are already tight. If this one fails I will try nylon with a heated enclosure and pray.

Inicia sesión o únete para responder.